Our Top Picks – Best Smelling Aftershave for Men 2020

Aftershave is a liquid product that is meant to be applied to the face after a shaving session. Its primary purpose is to prevent infection of cuts and reduce skin irritation. However, many aftershaves come with a fragrance or essential oil to enhance the scent.

Aftershave is often confused with eau de cologne due to the similarity between the two products. Many companies even encourage their customers to use their aftershaves as cologne in an effort to increase sales.

Aftershave is useful in providing a cool and refreshing feel after a potentially irritating shave. After the first few seconds of burn, the skin tightens up to prevent dirt and bacteria from getting lodged in the pores. It can also eliminate unwanted dirt on the skin which is the main cause of dullness. This property is especially useful to men who are not in the habit of washing their faces very often.

Besides its usefulness in maintaining facial hygiene, aftershaves that have a fragrance are useful in making a good first impression on people because a good scent lets people know that you are a man who takes care of himself.

After reviewing all the top smelling aftershave available, we’ve selected our top 6 picks in the comparison table below. We’re confident you’ll find the perfect model for your needs.


Comparison table

Mobile Users: Please turn-off ad block and tilt your phone to landscape

Lucky Tiger After Shave and Face Tonic image
best price cta
Lucky TigerEditor's Choice
Proraso After Shave Lotion image
best price cta
AUBREY Aftershave image
best price cta
Cartier Eau de Toilette Spray image
best price cta

Havana Aftershave Splash image
best price cta
Royall Lyme Aftershave Lotion image
best price cta
Royall Lyme7/10

Benefits of Using a Scented Aftershave

Let’s go into more detail regarding the benefits of using a scented aftershave.


The main purpose of a men’s aftershave is to soothe, nourish and moisturize the skin, stimulate cell regeneration, and help maintain clean, healthy skin. It has antiseptic properties to help prevent infection of cuts and acts as an astringent to reduce skin irritation. Some aftershaves contain moisturizers, either natural or artificial, which help to soften the skin.


Your scent is an invisible part of your style and has a powerful effect on how people see and remember you. This fact gives you numerous indirect benefits, such as making you more attractive and helping you feel more confident and less stressed. A nice aftershave fragrance adds to your overall image of a sharp, put-together man.

We all know that dressing well is a confidence booster; wearing a good fragrance simply enhances that. If you look like a million bucks, what’s the harm in smelling like it too?

Things to Consider When Buying the Best Smelling Aftershave For Men

aftershave image


The fragrance is obviously the most important factor you will look into when shopping for the best scented aftershave. But this is not as simple as it sounds. Some scents last longer on some people than they do on others. Some even smell different on different people.

Body chemistry and skin type have a lot to do with the duration of a fragrance. Essential oils, which are the main ingredient of fragrances, tend to dissipate quickly when applied to dry skin. On the other hand, they tend to last longer when applied to an oily skin. The solution for those with dry skin is to apply the manliest aftershave to oilier (moisturized) parts of the body like the temples or behind the ears.

Good fragrances are multi-layered, meaning that they will appeal to your sense of smell in three stages: top, middle, and base. The top layer is the one you will notice first and dissipates very soon after application. The middle layer forms the bulk of the fragrance and follows the top layer. The base layer comes out after the top layer is completely gone, and combines with the middle layer to give you that long-lasting aroma that follows you around throughout the day.

This is why it is important to sample the aftershave on your own skin before buying it. Smelling it from the bottle will only give you the top layer of the fragrance.

You will also want to think about sillage. This is the amount of fragrance you leave behind when walking through a room, much like the wake of a boat or the trail of a plane. The amount of sillage depends on the fragrance, and it is important to know this before making a purchase. Some people with sensitive noses are averse to fragrances that provide too much sillage.

Now let’s take a look at some of our favorite best smelling aftershaves for men.

6 Top Rated Scented Mens Aftershave Reviewed

1. Lucky Tiger - With Face Tonic


Modeled after the classic aftershave brand for men, Luck Tiger soothes, tones and invigorates the skin to make you look defined, confident and ready for anything.

It has a subtle citrusy orange, tangerine and grapefruit scent that dissipates, allowing you to complement it with your favorite cologne. It can be applied directly from your hands over your entire face and neck, or liberally with a cotton ball.

Reviewers find the fragrance of Lucky Tiger to be light, but able to hold up against the hot and humid weather of the tropics. It does a good job soothing razor burn and keeps the face smooth and soft like a good skin conditioner. It is alcohol-free, so it does not burn the skin upon application. It is very thin and absorbs into the skin very well. It doesn’t dry out the skin, which leads to clearer, smoother skin in the long run. It tones the skin will and has a gentle astringent quality to it.

Some reviewers did not like the smell of this aftershave, but this is an entirely subjective point of criticism. It is always a good idea to smell an aftershave, or any scented product, for yourself before making the decision to buy it.

2. Proraso - Lotion

This old-fashioned formula is made from well selected natural ingredients that can cool and tone the skin by giving you a feeling of relief after each shave. It contains eucalyptus oil, which tones and cleanses the skin and your facial hair, and menthol, which helps to enliven and rejuvenate your skin.

Devised for all skin types, this product is a pleasing and energizing habit that you can do every day to prep you up with your shaving routine. The best way to use this lotion is to massage it gently into your face immediately after shaving.

Reviewers of this best-selling product find the smell to be mild and pleasant, and not at all overpowering; an excellent choice for men who like to be conservative with their fragrances. It has very little alcohol sting but does have an amazing menthol smell and kick to it. It does have a slight burn when applied to nicks and cuts, but it is very mild, more like it is providing you with feedback about how well you shaved.

Some reviewers complain that this top rated aftershave left their skin feeling weird or breaking out in a rash. Like any other beauty product, it is a good idea to do your research, to check for allergies, and to try the product on your skin before buying it.

3. Aubrey - All Natural

This aftershave lotion invigorates your face and tightens your pores, leaving your skin feeling smooth, fresh and smelling great. Its classic pine scent is cool and invigorating and creates a cool, tingly sensation on the skin. Aubrey Organics Aftershave is free of sulfates, parabens, and phthalates.

The fragrance has a masculine and fresh outdoor smell. It works well at preventing burns, irritation, and redness. This natural formula is an excellent choice for men with sensitive skin, as it does not cause the skin to break out in any kind of allergic reaction. Some reviewers find that the scent dissipates completely soon after application.

This is a natural product so the scent will not be as strong as an expensive eau de cologne. However, if you prefer a stronger scent than this, it can be mixed with a few drops of a stronger scent like Brut. One reviewer who tried this said it worked beautifully and didn’t drown out the North Woods scent of the manliest aftershave.

4. Cartier - Woody Fragrance

Declaration for Men is a woody, floral, musk fragrance for men that is meant for romantic occasions. It is made from natural ingredients like mandarin orange, bergamot, neroli, bitter orange, orris, ginger, cinnamon, vetiver, oakmoss, and cedar, to name a few.

This scent lasts for several hours if not the whole day. It is a manly scent that is good for the office or on a date. The citrus tones are the most prominent, and it is a smash hit with the ladies.

Many reviewers expressed concern that this spray is a Cartier knock-off. Again, you have to keep in mind that big famous brands like Cartier will have fakes floating around in the market.

Do your research, find a genuine dealer and smell the product for yourself if you know what it smells like. If not, then take a friend along who has a sensitive nose and knows what it smells like and make sure you are paying for the original product.

5. HAVANA - Moisturizing

This tobacco-scented aftershave is light, can moisturize your skin, less-greasy contains Vit E and a little of menthol to give you that cooling effect.

It also contains crushed cocoa beans, Peruvian clove, vanilla, and Patchouli, reminiscent of the old Havana charm and glamor. Soothing to cuts and irritation, this serves as a supplement to your skin, can bring out the natural moisture of the skin and absorbs quickly. It is also free of synthetic chemicals like sulfates and parabens.

As advertised, this aftershave balm is reminiscent of Havana and lingers throughout the day. One reviewer was deliberately rough with his double-edged razor and confirms that it is, in fact, soothing to cuts and nicks. A tiny dab of it is enough for a day’s worth of scent. The menthol gives a cooling effect immediately after applying. Some reviewers found the scent to be a little bit overpriced.

However, with the tobacco scent and soothing property that this after shave offers, we think it is more than worth it.

6. Royall Lyme - Ideal for Romantic Wear

Introduced in 1957, this fragrance is made using lime oil blended with rare essential oils from all over the world. It is recommended for casual occasions.

Reviewers love the scent of this aftershave. It is subtle and does not last too long, which is a good thing when you are at a casual event. This product is also good in the heat and humidity of the tropics. One reviewer with sensitive skin says it is very soothing, yet enticing and exciting, and does not bother his allergies.

Detractors of this product had a problem with the scent. Some said it did not smell like lime while others said it was too overpowering. If it doesn’t smell like lime, it might be a fake, so make sure you do your research and buy your best aftershave from a genuine dealer. If it is too overpowering, then it is likely that you are using too much. A few drops are all that is needed from a scented aftershave.


In conclusion, scented aftershaves are very popular among men, primarily for their masculine scents and then their antifungal, antibacterial and overall therapeutic properties. Whether you buy one of these best men smelling aftershave or not, please remember the few key points we made about shopping for cheap aftershaves.

Always make sure you know what you are allergic to before going shopping. Always test a product on your skin before buying it. Remember to buy according to your skin type. Remember to wait for the top layer to dissipate, so that you can get an idea of the overall scent. And don’t forget to check the sillage of any best aftershave that catches your attention.

If you are still in doubt, then go for Proraso After Shave Lotion. It is definitely the most popular and the best aftershave brand among young men and old alike. It is mild and pleasant, a good choice aftershave list for men who prefer subtle fragrances as opposed to the overpowering ones that stick around hours after you have left the room. It has very little alcohol sting but does pack quite a menthol kick. And it does not burn too much when applied to nicks and cuts.

Just remember to test it on your own skin to make sure you don’t have any allergies to it or to any of the ingredients in it. At the end of the day, when push comes to shove, Proraso After Shave Lotion is guaranteed to make you feel more poised, good-looking and macho than any other top-notch aftershave!

Other Related Articles